Verdict on Vichy

June 1, 2003
Was the wartime Vichy regime a helpless victim or an enthusiastic collaborator in Nazi crimes? That question has been the cause of much controversy in France, and according to this comprehensive indictment,"the verdict on Vichy must be guilty." Rutgers political science professor Curtis argues that Vichy's anti-Semitic policies were"a deliberate, autonomous French government policy rather than...a response to German pressure." Vichy passed laws to strip Jews of their civil rights, seize their assets and exclude them from most professions. Worse, the French police apparatus organized and carried out the rounding up of Jews for deportation to the death camps, a task that the small German police contingent in France would have been hard-pressed to accomplish. With more freedom of action than most of occupied Europe, Curtis argues, Vichy was far more complicit in the Final Solution, especially in comparison with occupied Denmark and even the Axis governments in Bulgaria and Fascist Italy, which took concerted action--or at the very least, were less inclined to enforce discriminatory laws--to protect Jews under their jurisdiction. Curtis sets Vichy policy in the context of pre-war right wing and anti-Semitic political tendencies, and explores the post-war consensus that sought to downplay Vichy collaboration in favor of a mythology of heroic national Resistance to the Germans. He goes beyond the Vichy officials themselves to explore the acquiescence or silence of French society--the legal establishment, Church leaders, even left intellectuals like Sartre and de Beauvoir--in the face of anti-Semitic persecution. Drawing on the latest research, Curtis provides a comprehensive, nuanced but morally uncompromising look at France's darkest hour. 8 pages of b&w photos.

June 15, 2003
Drancy. Vel d'Hiv. Petain. These are just a few words that evoke one of the darkest times in France's history: the Vichy government of 1940-44. Curtis (political science, Rutgers Univ.) has written a detailed condemnation of Vichy's treatment of its Jewish population. Although at the time leaders claimed to be shielding their population from the German occupation, it is clear from Curtis's study that anti-Semitism was rooted in France's history. By 1944, over 75,000 Jews were deported; only about 2500 survived. Reading like a prosecutorial transcript, Curtis's study delineates Vichy's sins by using newly available documentation and statistics and covering subjects such as xenophobia, Aryanization, the church, the law, persecution, and collaboration. Although Curtis does not ignore noble acts performed by French men and women, he does conclude that Vichy is overwhelmingly "guilty." As the "verdict" in this book applies primarily to the Jewish experience, readers will want to have Robert O. Paxton's classic Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order, 1940-1944 and the newest comprehensive history by Julian Jackson, France: The Dark Years 1940- 1944. An important work for academic libraries.-Maria C. Bagshaw, Lake Erie Coll. Lib., Painesville, OH

Copyright 2003 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.